State v. Stack
SimpleOriginal

Summary

In this 2020 Nebraska case, Alan Stack claimed his severe alcohol use disorder caused a blackout negating intent in a fatal assault. The court held voluntary intoxication cannot support insanity and upheld his murder conviction.

2020 | State Juristiction

State v. Stack

Keywords alcohol use disorder; blackout; negating intent; fatal assault; voluntary intoxication; insanity; murder
Open Case as PDF

Summary

In a 2020 Nebraska legal proceeding, the defendant, Alan Stack, asserted that his severe alcohol use disorder resulted in a blackout, which precluded the formation of criminal intent during an assault that proved fatal. The judicial body concluded that intoxication voluntarily induced does not establish a basis for an insanity defense. Consequently, the court affirmed the defendant's conviction for murder.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

In a 2020 Nebraska legal case, Alan Stack asserted that a severe alcohol use disorder caused a blackout, which prevented him from forming the necessary intent during a fatal assault. The court, however, determined that voluntary intoxication does not serve as a valid basis for an insanity defense. As a result, Stack's murder conviction was upheld.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

In a 2020 Nebraska legal case, Alan Stack argued that his severe alcohol use disorder caused a blackout, meaning he could not have intended to commit a fatal assault. The court, however, ruled that choosing to become intoxicated does not provide a basis for an insanity defense. Consequently, his murder conviction was upheld.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

In a Nebraska case from 2020, a man named Alan Stack said he drank too much alcohol and blacked out. He claimed this meant he did not plan to hurt someone in a deadly attack. However, the court decided that choosing to drink alcohol and get drunk cannot be used as an excuse for being insane. So, the court kept his conviction for murder.

Open Case as PDF

Footnotes and Citation

Cite

State v. Stack, 307 Neb. 773, 950 N.W.2d 611 (2020)

Highlights