State v. Carter; State v. Reite
SimpleOriginal

Summary

The WA Supreme Court upheld determinate resentences for Carter and Reite, ruling courts may impose terms less than LWOP for 18–20-year-olds under Monschke. Both showed rehabilitation; only Reite’s community custody term was struck.

2024 | State Juristiction

State v. Carter; State v. Reite

Keywords determinate resentences; LWOP; 18-20-year-olds; Monschke; rehabilitation; Anderson; rehabilitation
Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Washington Supreme Court has affirmed the determinate resentencing decisions for individuals Carter and Reite. The court's ruling established that judicial bodies possess the authority to impose defined sentencing terms, which are less severe than life imprisonment without parole, for offenders who committed crimes between the ages of eighteen and twenty. This precedent aligns with the principles set forth in the Monschke legal framework. Evidence presented indicated that both Carter and Reite had demonstrated successful rehabilitation efforts. A notable distinction in the outcome was that only the community custody component of Reite's sentence was subsequently vacated.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Washington State Supreme Court upheld the specific resentences given to two individuals, Carter and Reite. The court's decision affirms that for offenders who committed crimes between the ages of 18 and 20, courts are permitted to impose prison terms that are less severe than life without parole, in accordance with the Monschke ruling. Both Carter and Reite presented evidence of rehabilitation. Of their respective sentences, only Reite's community custody requirement was removed by the court.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Washington State Supreme Court confirmed the specific new sentences for Carter and Reite. The court ruled that judges have the authority to impose sentences shorter than life without parole for offenders aged 18 to 20, as guided by the Monschke case. Both Carter and Reite demonstrated that they had changed for the better. However, only the part of Reite's sentence involving community supervision was removed.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

Washington State's highest court approved new sentences for two men, Carter and Reite. The court decided that judges can give people aged 18 to 20 sentences shorter than life in prison with no chance to get out. This rule came from an earlier court case known as Monschke. Both Carter and Reite showed they had improved while in prison. However, the court only removed the part of Reite's sentence that required him to be supervised in the community.

Open Case as PDF

Footnotes and Citation

Cite

State v. Carter & State v. Reite, 548 P.3d 935 (Wash. 2024)

Highlights