McNeill v. U.S.
SimpleOriginal

Summary

In this Supreme Court case, the court held that for ACCA sentencing, courts must assess whether a prior drug offense was "serious" based on the maximum sentence at the time of conviction, not any later reduction in state law penalties.

2011 | Federal Juristiction

McNeill v. U.S.

Keywords drug offense; maximum sentence; time of conviction; state law penalties; prior drug offense; sentencing
Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court has established a principle for evaluating prior drug offenses in the context of sentencing under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA). For a drug offense to be classified as "serious" for ACCA application, its severity must be determined by the maximum potential sentence permitted under the law at the specific time the conviction was entered. Subsequent amendments or reductions in state-level penalties for that offense are not to be considered when making this assessment.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court has issued a ruling concerning how courts should evaluate the seriousness of a past drug offense when applying the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA) for sentencing. The Court determined that judges must base this assessment on the maximum sentence a person could have received for that drug crime at the time of their original conviction. Any later changes in state law that reduce the penalties for that specific offense should not be considered in this determination.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court has issued a ruling concerning how a past drug offense is evaluated for sentencing under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA). The Court decided that to determine if a previous drug crime is considered "serious," courts must base their assessment on the maximum sentence that could have been imposed for that offense at the time of the original conviction. Any subsequent changes or reductions in state law penalties for that type of offense do not alter how serious it is judged for ACCA sentencing.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The highest court in the country made a decision about sentences. When a judge needs to decide if an old drug crime was "serious" for a prison sentence, they must look at the longest time a person could have gone to jail when they were first found guilty. The judges should not use any new law that might have made the punishment less severe later on.

Open Case as PDF

Footnotes and Citation

Cite

563 U.S. 816, 131 S.Ct. 2218, 180 L.Ed.2d 35 (2011)

Highlights