Brady v. United States
SimpleOriginal

Summary

The Supreme Court held that a guilty plea is valid only if it is voluntary and a knowing, intelligent act made with sufficient awareness of the circumstances and consequences. It may be valid if influenced by risk of a harsh sentence.

1970 | Federal Juristiction

Brady v. United States

Keywords Supreme Court; guilty plea; valid; voluntary; knowing; intelligent act; awareness; circumstances; consequences; harsh sentence
Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court stipulated that for a guilty plea to be valid, it must be both voluntary and the product of a knowing, intelligent decision. This decision necessitates a comprehensive understanding of the associated circumstances and potential consequences. A plea's validity, however, is not necessarily undermined by the influence of a potential severe sentence.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court has determined that for a guilty plea to be considered legally valid, it must be offered voluntarily. The individual entering the plea must also possess a clear and intelligent understanding of the circumstances and the potential consequences. However, a plea can still be deemed valid even if the decision was influenced by the risk of receiving a more severe sentence at trial.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court decided that a guilty plea is considered proper only when it is given freely and with a clear understanding of the situation and its potential outcomes. Such a plea may still be acceptable, even if the person made the decision to avoid a very strict punishment.

Open Case as PDF

Summary

The Supreme Court has decided that a person's plea of "guilty" is only good if they choose to make it themselves. They must also understand what they are doing and what will happen because of it. A guilty plea can still be good even if the person made it because they were worried about getting a very strong punishment.

Open Case as PDF

Footnotes and Citation

Cite

Brady v. United States, 397 U.S. 742 (1970)

Highlights