Adverse Childhood Experiences and Police Contact in Canada
Alexander Testa
Benjamin Jacobs
Jennifer Thompson
Nelson Pang
Dylan B. Jackson
SimpleOriginal

Summary

This study found that high ACE exposure increased the likelihood of police contact. The findings show the link between childhood trauma and criminal justice system interactions, supporting a need for early intervention.

Adverse Childhood Experiences and Police Contact in Canada

Keywords Physical abuse; Child abuse; Neglect; Child abuse; Criminology

Abstract

A growing body of research has demonstrated that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for criminal justice system contact. However, much of this research is limited by (1) being conducted in the United States and (2) a lack of details on specific types of harmful experiences of criminal justice system contact, such as police contact characterized by intrusion or harassment. Using survey data from 940 individuals aged 16 to 30 in Canada from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors, this study investigates the relationship between ACEs and police contact, focusing on encounters involving intrusion or harassment. Results from logistic and multinomial logistic regression analyses reveal that individuals with high ACE exposure, particularly those with four or more ACEs,are more likely to have police contact, including experiences of intrusion and harassment. The results are significant in understanding the interplay between childhood trauma and later encounters with the criminal justice system, emphasizing the need for trauma-informed approaches in policing and healthcare. The study highlights the importance of early interventions to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent adverse outcomes in police interactions.

Introduction

Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) encompass a spectrum of traumatic events that transpire during formative developmental years (i.e., before 18years old), including but not limited to abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction (Felitti et al., 1998; Sacks & Murphey, 2018). The detrimental effects of ACEs are profound, impacting health and developmental outcomes across the lifespan (Bellis et al., 2019; Hughes et al., 2017; Kalmakis & Chandler, 2015). Recent data underscores the pervasive nature of ACEs, indicating that approximately three in five Canadian adults aged 45 to 85 years old have experienced at least one ACE (Joshi et al., 2021).

While ACEs are associated with several negative consequences over the life course, the extent to which ACEs are linked to distressing encounters with law enforcement remains insufficiently explored, particularly within the Canadian context. Adverse experiences during childhood and adolescence have detrimental impacts on behavioral health and development and can contribute to later conduct and interpersonal difficulties (Austin, 2018; Campbell et al., 2016). These difficulties often manifest as substance use, school truancy, and/or externalizing behaviors, which further increase the chances of police contact (Afifi et al., 2020; Baiden et al., 2020; Bevilacqua et al., 2021; Boccio et al., 2025; Henry et al., 2021; Hunt et al., 2017; Jackson et al., 2022; Poole et al., 2017). Several cross-sectional studies have previously reported significant correlations between experiencing ACEs and an increased likelihood of individuals coming into contact with the criminal justice system, including arrest and incarceration (Graf et al., 2021; Stinson et al., 2016). More recently, longitudinal research has provided additional evidence of a positive temporal relationship whereby those with early ACE exposures also report increased subsequent police contact (Jackson et al., 2022; Testa & Jackson, 2022; Testa et al., 2022a).

Notwithstanding the knowledge gained from this extant research regarding ACEs and criminal justice contact, several critical gaps exist. First, studies on ACEs and police contact have been almost exclusively conducted in the United States (Graf et al., 2021; Stinson et al., 2016; Testa & Jackson, 2022; Testa et al., 2022), with one study from the United Kingdom (Jackson et al., 2022). Expanding the knowledge of this relationship to contexts outside of the United States to Canada is pivotal due to the country’s unique social policies, healthcare system, and cultural mosaic, which may contribute to differing patterns of ACEs and subsequent interactions with law enforcement compared to the United States (Thomas & Sands, 2023). Additionally, differences in policing strategies and criminal justice policies between Canada and the United States could influence the nature and frequency of police contact among individuals with ACEs (Ben-Porat, 2008). Investigating the relationship between ACEs and police encounters across diverse national contexts is crucial to understanding the unique mechanisms that ACEs serve as a risk factor for criminal justice system contact across countries with different cultures and criminal justice systems, which will help to develop crosscultural strategies for prevention and intervention.

Second, there is an insufficient understanding of whether ACEs differentially impact police stop incidents that encompass encounters involving verbal or physical intrusion or harassment predicated on a person’s physical appearance, identity, or demographic profile. Indeed, prior research illustrates that individuals with greater ACE exposure are more likely to experience police stops (Jackson et al., 2022), arrests (Graf et al., 2021; Stinson et al., 2016; Testa et al., 2022), and unfair police treatment (i.e., unfairly stopped, searched, or questioned by the police) (Testa & Jackson, 2022). However, understanding the relationship between ACEs and specific adverse experiences with police contact rooted in diverse forms of unjust intrusion or harassment is critical because these forms of police interactions can severely harm one’s health and development over the life course (Baćak & Apel, 2020; Dennison & Finkeldey, 2021; Geller et al., 2014; Jackson et al., 2020; McFarland et al., 2018; Testa et al., 2022b; Turney, 2021).

This paper endeavors to fill the research mentioned above gaps by examining the relationship between ACEs and police contact within the Canadian context. Specifically, drawing on survey data from adolescents and young adults in Canada, the current study assesses the relationship between ACEs and encounters with the police, including instances involving intrusion or harassment.

Methods

The data used in this study were obtained from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (N=940; ages 16–30). The recruitment of the initial sample took place in November and December 2021 through Instagram and Snapchat advertisements, and a second round of data collection occurred in November and December 2022 by contacting original participants via email to participate in a follow-up survey. The data collection for this study was conducted online via Qualtrics. Participants were given the opportunity to enter a drawing for one of three Apple iPads as an incentive for their participation. Multiple techniques were employed to ensure data quality, including reCAPTCHA verification for the survey, attention checks, and honeypot items (Xu et al., 2022). Features on Qualtrics were also enabled to prevent participants from taking the survey multiple times and to prevent the survey from appearing on search engine searches. Ethical approval was obtained from the research ethics board at the University of Toronto (#41707), and written informed consent (via checkbox) was obtained from all participants.

Measures

Dependent Variables. Three dependent variables were measured in the follow-up survey, assessing the experiences of participants with police contact at any point prior to their completion of the study survey.

Police contact is a binary variable based on a question asking participants, “Have you ever been stopped, searched, or questioned by the police?” (1=yes; 0=no).

Police contact with intrusion is based on a question asking, “Now think about the time you were stopped by the police that stands out most in your mind. During this encounter, did the officer(s) [select all that apply]”: (a) use harsh language, (b) frisk or search you, (c) threaten physical force, (d) use physical force, (e) arrest you, or (f) other [respondent textual description of unjust police behavior]? (0=never stopped by police; 1=stopped without intrusion [stopped by police and responded “no” to items a–f], and 2=stopped with intrusion [stopped by police and responded “yes” to at least one item a–f]) (Alang et al., 2021).

Police contact with harassment is based on a question asking participants, “Have you ever felt you were harassed or made to feel inferior for any reason by the police [select all that apply]”: (a) no, (b) yes, based on my race, ethnicity, or skin color, (c) yes, based on my language or accent, (d) yes, based on my immigration status, (e) yes, based on my sexual orientation, (f) yes, based on my gender identity, (g) yes, based on my sex, (h) or yes, based on my physical appearance, or (i) other [i.e., age; disability]) (0=never stopped by police; 1=stopped without harassment [stopped by police and responded “no” to items a–i], and 2=stopped with harassment [stopped by police and responded “yes” to at least one item a–i] (Alang et al., 2021).

Independent Variables. ACEs were assessed at the follow-up survey and measured participants’ experiences prior to 18years of age. ACEs included abuse (physical, emotional, and sexual), household dysfunction (parental divorce, family violence, presence of substance abuse, family mental health challenges, suicide, or incarcerated member of the household), and neglect (emotional and physical). Each question had the response option of “no” or “yes” with yes responses indicating the presence of each ACE. The ACEs items were adapted from prior research (Felitti et al., 2019). These 15 binary measures were summed into a cumulative ACEs score (0–15), which was then used to create a categorical count of ACEs, including 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, or more ACEs. The specific ACE, including definition and participant prevalence, is listed in Supplemental Appendix A.

Control Variables. Sociodemographic variables included self-reported age, gender (cisgender woman, cisgender man; due to the small sample sizes, transgender and gender-expansive participants were collapsed into a single group), race/ethnicity (collapsed to White or non-White due to limited racial variation in the sample), sexual orientation (heterosexual, gay/lesbian, bisexual, or questioning, queer, other), relationship status (in a relationship or not in a relationship), personal income ($0–$24,999, $25–$49,999, $50,000– $74,999, or ≥$75,000), and highest competed education (high school diploma or less, college degree, master’s degree or higher). Supplemental models include additional control variables for involvement in violence and illicit drug use in the previous 12months.

Statistical Analysis

The relationship between ACEs and any police contact is assessed with multiple logistic regression. Multinomial logistic regression is used to assess the relationship between ACEs and (a) police stops with intrusion and (b) police stops with harassment, adjusting for control variables. We then perform two supplemental analyses: (1) assess the relationship between each specific ACE and the outcome variables, and (b) repeat the main analyses accounting for patterns of involvement in violent crime and illicit drug use. Across all analyses, multiple imputations with chained analysis were performed in Stata 17 (Stata Copr) to address missing data, resulting in 20 multiply imputed datasets. Statistical significance was determined using two-sided p<.05. All analyses were conducted using Stata 17.

Results

Sample Overview

Table 1 provides the summary statistics of the analytic sample. Over 1 in 5 (21.7%) respondents reported zero ACEs, 14.6% reported 1 ACE, 11.8% reported 2 ACEs, 11.3% reported 3 ACEs, and 40.7% reported 4 or more ACEs. Overall, 23.2% of participants reported experiencing any police contact, 10.8% reported police contact without intrusion, 12.3% reported police contact with intrusion, 14.5% reported police contact without harassment, and 8.6% reported police contact with harassment.

Table 1. Demographic Characteristics of Participants from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (N=940).

Variable

% Or mean

Police contact

Any police contact

23.2

Police contact with intrusion

Never stopped

76.8

Stopped without intrusion

10.8

Stopped with intrusion

12.3

Police stop with harassment

Never stopped

76.8

Stopped without harassment

14.5

Stopped with harassment

8.6

Number of ACEs

0

21.7

1

14.6

2

11.8

3

11.3

4+

40.7

Age [M (SD)]

23.3 (4.5)

Race/ethnicity

White

62.0

Non-White

38.0

Gender

Cisgender woman

57.0

Cisgender man

33.5

Transgender/gender expansive

9.5

Sexual orientation

Heterosexual

54.5

Gay/lesbian

9.4

Bisexual

17.6

Question, questioning, other

18.4

Relationship

Not in a relationship

47.9

In a relationship

52.1

Personal income

$0 to $24,999

46.8

$25,000 to $49,999

19.5

$50,000 to $74,999

16.9

≥$75,000

16.7

Highest completed education

High school diploma or less

33.6

Undergraduate/college

48.8

Masters or higher

17.7

Illicit drug use

27.8

Involvement in violent crime

5.1

Note. ACEs=adverse childhood experience; M=mean; SD=standard deviation

ACEs and Police Contact

Table 2 provides the multiple logistic regression of the number of ACEs and experiencing any police contact. After adjusting for age, race/ethnicity, gender, sexual identity, income, and the highest level of education completed, respondents with four or more ACEs have a 77% higher odds of police contact relative to respondents with no ACEs (OR=1.77, 95% CI [1.13, 2.78]). The multinomial logistic regression results in Table 3 show that relative to the reference group of respondents with no ACEs and the base outcome of no police contact, having four or more ACEs is associated with a 108% higher risk of police contact with intrusion (relative risk ratios [RRR]=2.08 [1.17, 3.71]) and 325% higher risk of police contact with harassment (RRR=4.25 [1.83, 9.86]), even after adjusting for age, race/ethnicity, gender, sexual identity, income, and highest level of education completed.

Table 2. Associations Between the Number of ACEs and Any Police Contact Among Participants in the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (N=940)

Variables

AOR [95% CI]a

p

Number of ACEs

0

Ref.

Ref.

1

1.14 [0.64, 2.01]

.655

2

0.86 [0.44, 1.67]

.652

3

1.05 [0.56, 1.99]

.871

4+

1.77 [1.13, 2.78]

.013

Note. Values in bold are significant with p<.05. ACEs=adverse childhood experience; AOR=adjusted odds ratio. a Analyzes adjusted for age, race/ethnicity, gender, sexual identity, income, and highest level of education completed.

Supplementary Analysis

We conducted supplementary analyses of the models in Tables 2 and 3 by expanding control variables to include involvement in violence and illicit drug use in the past 12months. Supplemental Appendix B shows that even after controlling for violence and illicit drug use, in addition to the previous control variables, a positive association remains between four or more ACEs and any police contact. However, the relationship is partially attenuated (OR=1.59, 95% CI [1.00, 2.52]). Supplemental Appendix C shows that while controlling for these variables, a relationship remains between four or more ACEs and having reported police stop with intrusion (RRR=1.86 [1.04, 3.35]) and police stop with harassment (RRR=3.71 [1.58, 8.68]) compared to those reporting no police contact and no ACEs. Supplemental Appendices D and E replicate the main analyses, examining the relationship of each specific ACE item on any police contact, police contact with intrusion, and police contact with harassment. Appendices F to I reproduce the results using a top-coding of ACEs at ≥5 or ≥6 ACEs. Finally, Supplemental Appendix J plots the predicted probabilities of police contact by a discrete count of ACEs.

Discussion

Summary of Findings

Using a sample of adolescents and young adults from Canada, the current study finds that high ACE exposure—especially four or more ACEs—was associated with a greater likelihood of having any police contact and a greater risk for negative interactions with the police, including police contact with intrusion and police contact with harassment. Moreover, these results remain after adjusting for race/ethnicity, gender, sexual identity, income, and education levels, and persist even when accounting for previous patterns of involvement in violent crime and substance use. To our knowledge, this study is the first to show a relationship between ACEs and police contact in Canada and corroborates prior literature using samples from other countries, such as the United States (Fleming & Nurius, 2020; Graf et al., 2021; Stinson et al., 2016; Testa & Jackson, 2022; Testa et al., 2022a; Zettler et al., 2018) and the United Kingdom (Jackson et al., 2022).

Screenshot 2025-04-20 at 09.17.44

Participants in this study were particularly diverse in terms of their gender, with 9.5% of participants having identified as transgender or gender expansive and sexual minority orientation, with 36% who identified as bisexual, queer, questioning, or other (17.6% bisexual; 18.4% queer, questioning, or other). Previous studies have highlighted a significant increase in the odds of police contact for persons of gender and sexual minority status compared to heterosexual individuals in Canada (Testa et al., 2024). Future work studying the relationships between ACEs and police contact in Canada and, more broadly, should seek to collect more nuanced data on gender and sexual minority membership, especially given findings indicating that police stops perceived as unfair occur more frequently for sexual minority women than sexual minority men (Baćak et al., 2021).

ACEs, encompassing a range of traumatic childhood experiences, have long been associated with adverse health outcomes (Bellis et al., 2019; Felitti et al., 1998; Hughes et al., 2017; Kalmakis & Chandler, 2015). The elevated likelihood of police contact with intrusion or harassment among those with high ACE exposure underscores the interconnectedness of early life traumatic experiences and subsequent contact with the criminal justice system (Graf et al., 2021). The heightened risk of police interactions observed in this study among those with high ACE exposure raises concerns about the potential retraumatization of individuals who have experienced significant early adversity, especially considering the link between adverse experiences with police contact and post-traumatic stress responses (Dennison & Finkeldey, 2021; DeVylder et al., 2020; Gearhart et al., 2022a, 2022b, 2023; Jackson, 2021; Jackson et al., 2019; Turney, 2021).

Policy Implications

These results also have significant implications for the Canadian criminal justice system. The increased likelihood of police contact with intrusion or harassment among young adults with four or more ACEs suggests that the system may inadvertently exacerbate the vulnerabilities of this already marginalized population that has endured a great deal of trauma. Policymakers and criminal justice professionals should consider trauma-informed approaches that address the history of trauma and adversity experienced by individuals (Bateson et al., 2020; Gill et al., 2016). Hosting seminars and training sessions led by trauma-informed professional counselors or public health experts can teach police and policymakers alike to serve and view the world through an ACEs lens. In practice, using trauma-informed language can foster connection and alleviate the traumatic victimization these individuals have endured throughout their interaction with the justice system (Bateson et al., 2020). In addition, the implementation of de-escalation training for police officers is a promising avenue to reduce the prevalence of negative police-citizen encounters. Such training can provide officers with essential skills in communication, empathy, and conflict resolution, potentially decreasing the incidence of violent confrontations and improving overall public safety (Bennell et al., 2020; Engel et al., 2020). The findings also underscore the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration between public health and criminal justice sectors to develop policies and practices prioritizing the well-being and rehabilitation of individuals with ACEs, ultimately contributing to a more equitable criminal justice system (Jackson, 2021).

Furthermore, as the Canadian health system strives to address health inequities and promote a holistic approach to well-being, these findings underscore the need for targeted interventions and support systems that recognize the complex interplay between childhood trauma, mental health, and interactions with the criminal justice system. In particular, healthcare providers play a pivotal role in identifying and mitigating the impacts of these intertwined challenges to promote resilience and well-being among individuals with high ACE exposure (Barnes et al., 2020; Rariden et al., 2021). Screening tools and strategies can be instrumental in this endeavor, helping providers identify at-risk persons and tailor interventions accordingly (Chandler et al., 2015; Lanier et al., 2018). By systematically assessing ACEs and police contact experiences, healthcare professionals can better understand patients’ unique needs and offer targeted services such as trauma-informed care, mental health support, and community resources essential for mitigating trauma and fostering healing (Dube, 2018; Oral et al., 2016). This holistic approach underscores the vital role healthcare providers can play in breaking the cycle of trauma and supporting individuals on their path to improved health (Kalmakis & Chandler, 2015; Kia-Keating et al., 2019).

Limitations

The current study has limitations that offer opportunities for further exploration in future research. First, the data were collected using non-random probability sampling methods and, as such, did not represent the entire Canadian population. While there is demographic diversity, and the sample included participants from all Canadian provinces and territories except Prince Edward Island, it is important to note that the online recruitment strategy may have introduced selection bias if there was a disproportionate response by those with higher ACE exposures. Second, the data originated from a survey inquiring about police contact and ACEs, which relied on retrospective self-reported measures, potentially introducing reporting biases. Nonetheless, self-reports remain the prevailing method for gathering information on both experiences with police contact and ACEs. Third, the data are cross-sectional; therefore, we cannot determine the timing of police contact in individuals’ life courses or evaluate patterns of recurrent police interactions over time. To address these limitations, a significant avenue for future research in Canada would involve addressing the questions raised in this study using nationally representative data drawn from probability sampling methods, making findings more generalizable. Finally, work that includes the acquisition of longitudinal data on ACEs and police contact, especially from more racially diverse samples, would be worthwhile.

Conclusions

Using a recent national sample of adolescents and young adults from Canada, this study found a positive relationship between the accumulation of ACEs and experiences with police contact, including police contact with intrusion and police contact with harassment. These findings suggest that high ACE exposure—particularly four or more ACEs—serves as a risk factor for intrusive experiences with police. Given that both ACEs and negative police contact have wide-ranging consequences for health over the life course, these findings underscore the critical need for early interventions to mitigate the negative effects of ACE exposure.

Abstract

A growing body of research has demonstrated that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for criminal justice system contact. However, much of this research is limited by (1) being conducted in the United States and (2) a lack of details on specific types of harmful experiences of criminal justice system contact, such as police contact characterized by intrusion or harassment. Using survey data from 940 individuals aged 16 to 30 in Canada from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors, this study investigates the relationship between ACEs and police contact, focusing on encounters involving intrusion or harassment. Results from logistic and multinomial logistic regression analyses reveal that individuals with high ACE exposure, particularly those with four or more ACEs,are more likely to have police contact, including experiences of intrusion and harassment. The results are significant in understanding the interplay between childhood trauma and later encounters with the criminal justice system, emphasizing the need for trauma-informed approaches in policing and healthcare. The study highlights the importance of early interventions to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent adverse outcomes in police interactions.

Summary

Research indicates a significant correlation between adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) and negative interactions with law enforcement, although this relationship remains under-researched, particularly within the Canadian context. Existing literature predominantly focuses on United States data, neglecting the influence of unique social, healthcare, and cultural factors within Canada. This study addresses this gap by examining the association between ACEs and various forms of police contact among Canadian adolescents and young adults, including intrusive and harassing encounters.

Methods

Data were drawn from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (N=940; ages 16–30), collected via online surveys using Qualtrics. Recruitment utilized social media platforms and email follow-ups, with incentives provided for participation. Rigorous data quality control measures were implemented, including verification mechanisms, attention checks, and prevention of duplicate submissions. Ethical approval and informed consent were obtained.

Measures

Three dependent variables assessed police contact experiences: (1) any police contact (binary); (2) police contact with intrusion (categorical, encompassing harsh language, searches, threats, or physical force); and (3) police contact with harassment (categorical, based on perceived harassment due to various identity factors). Independent variables included a cumulative ACEs score (0–15) derived from fifteen binary ACE items (abuse, neglect, household dysfunction). Control variables comprised sociodemographic factors (age, gender, race/ethnicity, sexual orientation, relationship status, income, education) and, in supplemental analyses, involvement in violence and illicit drug use.

Statistical Analysis

Multiple logistic regression analyzed the relationship between ACEs and any police contact. Multinomial logistic regression examined the association between ACEs and police contact with intrusion/harassment. Supplemental analyses investigated individual ACEs and the impact of violence/drug use. Multiple imputation addressed missing data.

Results

The sample exhibited a wide range of ACEs exposure (21.7% reported zero ACEs, 40.7% reported four or more). A substantial percentage (23.2%) reported police contact. Multiple logistic regression revealed significantly higher odds of any police contact among individuals with four or more ACEs (OR=1.77). Multinomial regression showed increased risk of police contact with intrusion (RRR=2.08) and harassment (RRR=4.25) for this group. Supplemental analyses indicated that these relationships persisted even after controlling for violence and drug use.

Discussion

This study demonstrates a robust association between high ACE exposure and increased likelihood of police contact, particularly negative interactions. These findings highlight the need for trauma-informed approaches within the Canadian criminal justice system, emphasizing de-escalation training and interdisciplinary collaboration between public health and law enforcement. The study underscores the importance of proactive interventions to mitigate the long-term effects of ACEs on individuals' well-being and engagement with the justice system.

Limitations

Limitations include the non-random sampling method, reliance on self-reported data, and cross-sectional design, potentially introducing bias and limiting causal inferences. Future research employing probability sampling, longitudinal data, and diverse samples is needed to strengthen the generalizability of these findings.

Conclusions

This study reveals a significant positive relationship between ACEs and police contact in a Canadian sample. The high prevalence of negative police encounters among those with high ACE exposure necessitates the development and implementation of trauma-informed practices within the criminal justice system and broader healthcare settings to support vulnerable populations.

Abstract

A growing body of research has demonstrated that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for criminal justice system contact. However, much of this research is limited by (1) being conducted in the United States and (2) a lack of details on specific types of harmful experiences of criminal justice system contact, such as police contact characterized by intrusion or harassment. Using survey data from 940 individuals aged 16 to 30 in Canada from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors, this study investigates the relationship between ACEs and police contact, focusing on encounters involving intrusion or harassment. Results from logistic and multinomial logistic regression analyses reveal that individuals with high ACE exposure, particularly those with four or more ACEs,are more likely to have police contact, including experiences of intrusion and harassment. The results are significant in understanding the interplay between childhood trauma and later encounters with the criminal justice system, emphasizing the need for trauma-informed approaches in policing and healthcare. The study highlights the importance of early interventions to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent adverse outcomes in police interactions.

Summary

Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are significantly associated with negative health and developmental outcomes throughout life. A substantial portion of the Canadian adult population reports experiencing at least one ACE. While research links ACEs to various negative consequences, the connection between ACEs and negative interactions with law enforcement in Canada requires further investigation. This study addresses this gap by examining the relationship between ACEs and police contact among Canadian adolescents and young adults.

Methods

Data were drawn from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (N=940; ages 16–30), collected online via Qualtrics in 2021 and 2022. Recruitment utilized social media advertisements and email follow-ups. Data quality was ensured through various methods including reCAPTCHA verification, attention checks, and honeypot items. Ethical approval and informed consent were obtained.

Measures

Dependent variables included: police contact (binary); police contact with intrusion (ordinal, accounting for harsh language, physical force, etc.); and police contact with harassment (ordinal, based on perceived harassment due to race, ethnicity, etc.). The independent variable was a cumulative ACEs score (0-15), derived from 15 binary measures of abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction. Control variables included sociodemographic factors.

Statistical Analysis

Multiple logistic regression analyzed the relationship between ACEs and any police contact. Multinomial logistic regression examined the association between ACEs and police contact with intrusion/harassment. Multiple imputation addressed missing data. Statistical significance was set at p<.05.

Results

The sample showed considerable ACE exposure (40.7% reporting 4 or more ACEs). A significant association existed between four or more ACEs and increased odds of any police contact (OR=1.77), police contact with intrusion (RRR=2.08), and police contact with harassment (RRR=4.25), even after adjusting for control variables. Supplemental analyses, controlling for violence and illicit drug use, showed attenuated but persistent associations.

Discussion

This study demonstrates a strong link between high ACE exposure and increased likelihood of police contact, particularly negative interactions, among Canadian adolescents and young adults. These findings are consistent with research from other countries. The diverse sample highlights the need for further research considering gender and sexual minority experiences. The results underscore the potential for retraumatization during police interactions and the importance of trauma-informed approaches within the criminal justice system.

Policy Implications

The findings emphasize the need for trauma-informed practices within the Canadian criminal justice system, including de-escalation training for officers and interdisciplinary collaboration between public health and criminal justice sectors. Healthcare providers also have a crucial role in identifying and supporting individuals with high ACE exposure, implementing screening tools, and offering trauma-informed care.

Limitations

Limitations include the use of non-random sampling, reliance on retrospective self-reported data, and the cross-sectional nature of the study. Future research should employ probability sampling, longitudinal designs, and explore more nuanced data on gender and racial identities.

Conclusions

This study highlights the significant relationship between ACEs and negative police contact in Canada. Early interventions to mitigate the impact of ACEs are crucial, promoting a more equitable and trauma-informed criminal justice system.

Abstract

A growing body of research has demonstrated that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for criminal justice system contact. However, much of this research is limited by (1) being conducted in the United States and (2) a lack of details on specific types of harmful experiences of criminal justice system contact, such as police contact characterized by intrusion or harassment. Using survey data from 940 individuals aged 16 to 30 in Canada from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors, this study investigates the relationship between ACEs and police contact, focusing on encounters involving intrusion or harassment. Results from logistic and multinomial logistic regression analyses reveal that individuals with high ACE exposure, particularly those with four or more ACEs,are more likely to have police contact, including experiences of intrusion and harassment. The results are significant in understanding the interplay between childhood trauma and later encounters with the criminal justice system, emphasizing the need for trauma-informed approaches in policing and healthcare. The study highlights the importance of early interventions to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent adverse outcomes in police interactions.

Summary

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are traumatic events occurring before age 18, such as abuse, neglect, or household dysfunction. These experiences significantly impact health and development throughout life. A substantial portion of Canadian adults have reported experiencing at least one ACE. While research links ACEs to negative life outcomes, the connection between ACEs and negative interactions with law enforcement, particularly in Canada, needs further investigation.

Methods

Researchers used data from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors (940 participants aged 16–30). Data collection involved online surveys, incentivized by a prize draw, and employed measures to ensure data quality. Ethical approval and informed consent were obtained.

Measures

The study measured three types of police contact: any police contact, police contact involving intrusion (harsh language, physical force, etc.), and police contact involving harassment (based on race, gender, etc.). ACEs were assessed using a cumulative score based on various types of abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction. Control variables included demographics like age, gender, race, income, and education.

Statistical Analysis

Multiple and multinomial logistic regression analyses were used to examine the relationship between ACEs and the different types of police contact, adjusting for control variables. Additional analyses explored the relationship of specific ACEs and accounted for violence and drug use.

Results

Over 40% of participants reported four or more ACEs. Around 23% reported any police contact. After adjusting for various factors, individuals with four or more ACEs showed a significantly higher likelihood of any police contact, contact with intrusion, and contact with harassment. These associations remained even after accounting for violence and drug use.

Discussion

Summary of Findings

The study revealed a strong link between high ACE exposure and increased likelihood of negative police interactions in Canadian youth. This supports previous research from other countries. The sample included diverse participants in terms of gender and sexual orientation.

Policy Implications

These findings highlight the need for trauma-informed approaches within the Canadian criminal justice system. Training for police officers in de-escalation techniques and trauma-informed communication is crucial. Collaboration between public health and criminal justice sectors is essential to support individuals with ACEs. Healthcare providers also have a role in identifying and addressing the impact of ACEs on individuals’ well-being.

Limitations

The study's limitations include its non-random sampling method, reliance on self-reported data, and cross-sectional design. Future research using nationally representative data and longitudinal designs is needed.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates a significant relationship between ACEs and negative experiences with police in Canada. Early interventions are needed to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent negative interactions with law enforcement.

Abstract

A growing body of research has demonstrated that adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are a risk factor for criminal justice system contact. However, much of this research is limited by (1) being conducted in the United States and (2) a lack of details on specific types of harmful experiences of criminal justice system contact, such as police contact characterized by intrusion or harassment. Using survey data from 940 individuals aged 16 to 30 in Canada from the Canadian Study of Adolescent Health Behaviors, this study investigates the relationship between ACEs and police contact, focusing on encounters involving intrusion or harassment. Results from logistic and multinomial logistic regression analyses reveal that individuals with high ACE exposure, particularly those with four or more ACEs,are more likely to have police contact, including experiences of intrusion and harassment. The results are significant in understanding the interplay between childhood trauma and later encounters with the criminal justice system, emphasizing the need for trauma-informed approaches in policing and healthcare. The study highlights the importance of early interventions to mitigate the effects of ACEs and prevent adverse outcomes in police interactions.

Summary

Hard times during childhood can affect people's lives in big ways. This study looked at how tough childhood experiences, called ACEs (Adverse Childhood Experiences), are linked to problems with the police. It used information from Canadian teens and young adults.

Methods

Researchers collected information from 940 people aged 16 to 30 in Canada. They used online surveys to ask about bad experiences in childhood and encounters with police. They made sure the survey was safe and that people only took it once. They got permission from an ethics board to do the study.

Measures

The study looked at three things: if people had ever been stopped by police, if the police were rough or mean during those stops, and if people felt harassed by the police. It also looked at different kinds of tough childhood experiences like abuse, neglect, and problems at home. It considered things like age, gender, race, and how much money people made.

Statistical Analysis

Researchers used special math to see how childhood experiences related to police problems. They checked if the results were still true even after considering other things.

Results

More than 40% of people had four or more tough childhood experiences. About 23% had some kind of trouble with the police. People with four or more bad childhood experiences were much more likely to have problems with the police, especially if the police were rough or mean.

Sample Overview

The study included a mix of people with different backgrounds.

ACEs and Police Contact

The study showed a strong link between many tough childhood experiences and problems with the police.

Supplementary Analysis

Even after considering other things like getting into fights or using drugs, the link between tough childhood experiences and police trouble still existed.

Discussion

Summary of Findings

This study shows a link between tough childhood experiences and problems with the police in Canada. It's the first study of its kind in Canada. It also showed that people with tough childhood experiences were more likely to have really bad encounters with the police.

Policy Implications

The study shows that the justice system might make things worse for people who've already had a hard time. It suggests that police should be trained to understand trauma and be kinder. It also means that healthcare workers should help people who have had these bad experiences.

Limitations

The study used online surveys, so not everyone in Canada was included. Also, people might not remember things perfectly or might not want to tell the truth. It only looked at one point in time, not how things change over time.

Conclusions

This study shows a big connection between tough childhood experiences and problems with the police. This means helping kids who have hard times is very important.

Highlights